Instructions to Reviewers

Last updated

Thank you for reviewing for JTEDS. Reviews are double-blind: do not try to identify the authors, and do not reveal your identity in your comments.

  • Accept an invitation only if the manuscript is within your expertise and you have no conflict of interest.
  • Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not upload it to AI tools or share it with anyone.
  • Score each section of the review form and give comments the authors can act on.
  • Recommend one of: accept as it is, minor revision, moderate revision, major revision, or reject, with your reasons for the editor.

Before you accept

An invitation shows you the title and the abstract. The manuscript itself is available once you have accepted. When you accept, you confirm that you have no conflict of interest with the work that you know of, and that you will keep the manuscript and your review confidential. If you recognise the authors from the work and are close to them (the same institution, a recent co-author, a supervisor or student), decline.

Your name

The authors are not told who reviewed their manuscript. If you return an annotated copy, your name is removed from its properties, comments and tracked changes before anybody else can read it. The journal thanks its reviewers on a public page once a year, and you are named there only if you ask to be, on your profile page.